Answer:

TIE

AnswerCrossword Clue
TIECause of overtime
TIEOne to one, e.g.
TIEOvertime cause
TIEPopular Father's Day gift
TIESudden-death causer
TIEUsual tic-tac-toe outcome
TIE17-17, e.g.
TIEAffiliation
TIEAll even
TIEAscot, essentially
TIECravat
TIEEven the score
TIENo-win score
TIENo-win situation
TIEPlace for a tack
TIESecure
TIEStandoff
TIETack or pin site
TIETrash-bag closer
TIECome out even
TIEFour-in-hand
TIEWord after lunch or railroad
TIEAvril Lavigne staple
TIEDraw
TIEMake the same points?
TIEOutcome added to the third column
TIEBind
TIEDead heat
TIEEven score
TIEOvertime creator
TIEBackgammon impossibility
TIETic-tac-toe yawner
TIE0-0, say
TIEReason for OT
TIEReason for sudden death
TIEReason to keep playing
TIEShootout cause
TIEWhite-collar accessory
TIEKnotted neckwear
TIERailroad beam