Answer: eerie

AnswerCrossword Clue
EERIELike Serling stories
EERIELike a King novel
EERIEMysterious
EERIEOtherworldly
EERIESounds like a lake
EERIESounds like a lake?
EERIEMore clearheaded
EERIEHard to explain, maybe
EERIELike noises of unfamiliar origin
EERIEToo weird
EERIEPeculiar
EERIELike "Goosebumps" stories
EERIELike a deserted ship at sea
EERIELike "Twilight Zone" episodes
EERIELike Poe's prose
EERIEHaunting
EERIEMore than odd
EERIESurreal
EERIEEggstraordinarily weird
EERIEPhantasmal
eeriestrange and mysterious; unsettling
EERIEWeird
EERIEInspiring dread
EERIELike a creaky door, perhaps
EERIELike howls in the night
EERIEOut of this world
EERIEReally strange
EERIESpooky
EERIEUncanny
EERIEUnconventional
EERIEUnearthly
EERIEEldritch
EERIECreepy
EERIEGooseflesh-making
EERIEHair-raising
EERIEHalloweenlike
EERIELike the Twilight Zone
EERIESpine-chilling
EERIESpine-tingling
EERIEA la (Stephen) King