Answer:

forme

AnswerCrossword Clue
FORME".. and My Gal"
FORMESurprised recipient's reply
FORMEGift-getter's question
FORMEResponse to an unexpected gift
FORME"... and My Gal"
FORME"Don't Cry ... Argentina" ("Evita" song)
FORME"But Not .. " (Gershwin tune)
FORMEGift getter's question
FORMEGift recipient's words
FORMEGift recipient's question
FORMEQuestion from a gift recipient
FORMELead-in to "You shouldn't have!"
FORMESurprised recipient's question
FORMEGift recipient's query
FORMEGift recipient's ingenuous question