Answer: whatthe

AnswerCrossword Clue
WHATTHE

"Huh?"

WHATTHE"Huh ...?!"
WHATTHE

Cry of surprise

WHATTHE

Dumbfounded expression

WHATTHE
Words said with a double take
WHATTHE
"Are you kidding me?!"
WHATTHECry of astonishment
WHATTHE"Seriously?!"
WHATTHE"Beg pardon?!"
WHATTHE"Can this be?!"
WHATTHE"Huh?!"
WHATTHE"Huh ...?"
WHATTHE"Hey...!"
WHATTHE"I don't believe my eyes!"
WHATTHECry accompanying a double take
WHATTHECry of disbelief